A New Telecom Act?

In October, the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society held an event titled “A New Compact for Connectivity: Internet Infrastructure in the Public Interest.” The purpose of the event was to take a fresh look at the kind of broadband regulations we need moving forward.

It was clear to everybody on the panels that the current regulatory scheme is broken and obsolete. Most current regulations are based on the Telecommunications Act of 1996. For the last fifteen years, most regulatory fights have revolved around whether broadband is a Title I or Title II service. It’s been a ridiculous spectacle, because regulators have picked sides based on their political leanings. Democrats believe that broadband is a Title II telecommunications service, while Republicans say it is a Title I information service. None of this back and forth between changes of administration has led to any meaningful broadband regulation.

It’s clear that what is needed is something new, and the panelists at the Benton event were all in favor of a new set of rules, which can only be accomplished with an updated telecom act. The current regulatory mess makes it hard to deal with common-sense consumer protection rules for things like reasonable prices, nondiscriminatory treatment, and communications privacy. While we hear a lot about increased competition, but a large number of people still only have one or two choices for broadband.

Congress now faces hurdles it didn’t have when the last telecom act was passed in 1996. The Supreme Court’s Loper Bright decision adds a new challenge by saying that courts don’t have to defer to expertise at regulatory agencies, and courts should only pay attention to responsibilities specifically described by law. That’s going to make it a challenge for Congress to write laws that will stay relevant and up to date in an industry like telecom where the landscape and technology is constantly changing.

There are a number of things a new telecom act could fix. For example, Congress could put to rest all of the controversy about the Universal Service Fund by specifically describing things like the relationship between the FCC and USAC. A new set of laws to reconstitute the USF would stop the incessant set of legal challenges to the USF that come from opponents who are looking at flaws in the rules written in 1996.

Congress could do anything it wanted in a new telecom act. Is it in favor of net neutrality? If so, then codify it. Does it favor stronger rules on protecting customer data? Then spell it out. Congress can vote to fix all of the controversies that have subsumed regulation for the last few decades. The timing of the 1996 Act was unfortunate since it preceded the Internet boom by only a few years. It’s time that we have a set of rules from Congress that meet the needs of today – and tomorrow.

One thought on “A New Telecom Act?”

  1. A good place to start is to clearly define advanced telecommunications as infrastructure as basic voice telecom was before it. Major problem is policymakers have defined the service it delivers without first defining and setting standards for the delivery infrastructure.

Leave a Reply