Smarter Broadband Infrastructure Grants

New Mexico recently released an RFI asking stakeholders how the state should decide on structuring future broadband grants. New Mexico remains as one of the states with the most broadband gaps, and it’s clear the state plans to continue to have grant programs to address the various gaps. The State has already launched a program to address broadband affordability that largely mimics what was offered by the federal ACP plan. But the state recognizes there are still a lot of other gaps.

This is something I’ve been thinking a lot about lately, because it’s also a big topic in Western North Carolina. This region also has a lot of broadband gaps, many of which were made worse by Hurricane Helene. There has been a lot of talk in the region about how we build back smarter.

The discussion in Western North Carolina and New Mexico acknowledges that there are still numerous infrastructure gaps that haven’t been filled by grant funding. Both regions, and much of the rest of the country, still have:

  • Pockets of folks who haven’t been reached by terrestrial broadband.
  • A lot of places where federal grants went for satellite service.
  • Major gaps in rural cellphone coverage.
  • Gaps in rural public safety networks.
  • A lot of people who live out of easy range of a health facility.
  • Anchor institutions that haven’t gotten fiber broadband.
  • Low-income housing complexes with inadequate broadband.
  • Hurricane Helene showed Western North Carolina is that there is also a huge gap in redundancy and resiliency in existing networks. Too many counties in the region had lengthy communications blackouts. We are now working on creating resiliency hubs where folks can go for emergency food, power, and WiFi after a disaster.
  • Middle-mile fiber to support all of the above.

I think the solution is to build smarter. It’s going to be tempting for New Mexico to launch grant programs that address only one specific issue, like lack of rural cell towers. While such grants will be welcome, they will spend infrastructure money without considering the many other broadband gaps.

There is a better way. What if every broadband infrastructure proposal was graded not on how it solved a specific issue, but also by how many other needs it could satisfy? This would be a new way to think about infrastructure grants.

There is a better way to tackle new grants today. We have the resources to map all of the gaps described above. Before New Mexico issues any infrastructure grants, it should first fund a broadband gap map that identifies every location that still needs an infrastructure solution. The map would show each of the gaps described above.

There is a logistical challenge in how to populate the gaps on the initial maps. There are already state  agencies that track some of the gaps. Other gaps can be identified by experts. For example, it’s not hard with AI to identify the places where a new cell tower would reach the most people who don’t have cell coverage today.

Creating such a map one time would be great, but the best use of the knowledge embedded in a broadband gap map would be to update it, at least annually. That would involve removing sites that have gotten a broadband solution in the last year, and adding new sites as people figure them out.

These maps would be made public. They would be of great value to ISPs since they would identify revenue opportunities they might not have known about. And of course, they would be invaluable when issuing middle-mile or last-mile infrastructure grants, since the maps would show areas with the greatest needs in a number of areas.

A broadband gap map could also unleash non-profit and other efforts. For example, health organizations might decide to bring solutions to the areas with poor health coverage. State public safety folks could identify the coverage gaps while also seeing the other benefits from issuing public safety grants. Identifying the areas with no redundancy can alert local officials to start clamoring for a solution.

Are Carriers Afraid of SpaceX?

The day after SpaceX announced plans to gain access to 80,000 cell sites in the U.S., the stocks of AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon all took an immediate hit. This means the stock market took SpaceX’s claim seriously, which means the carriers must do so as well. That announcement made it clear that SpaceX plans to become the fourth cellular carrier in the country in place of the defunct EchoStar

Carrier stock prices have continued to tumble. AT&T dropped from $24.87 on the day before the SpaceX announcement to $20.86 (16%) when I was writing this blog. T-Mobile dropped from $171.31 to $145.80 (15%), and Verizon dropped from $46.35 to $43.87 (5.5%).

The cellular industry stocks were already in duress, which is an odd thing to say about an industry that has been completely successful in getting practically every adult to subscribe to cellular service. However, the industry has become increasingly competitive. This competition is manifesting in ever-decreasing rates that come about through marketing specials. There probably has never been a better time for a customer who wants to save money to play the carriers off against each other.

The carriers are struggling to find other ways to fight against competition and churn. The most publicized way is the push to bundle cellular service and broadband. All three carriers have been offering a bundle of cellular phone service along with the cellular FWA broadband product. The discounts are mostly being given on the broadband side of the bundle, allowing the carriers to claim a high ARPU for cellular service.

At the end of August, Verizon announced a bundle of fiber broadband and cellular service – a bundle that seems to be decades too late. I’ve always wondered why the company didn’t figure out a way to do this when they were the early fiber leaders with Verizon FiOS broadband. The word at the time was that the cellular and broadband businesses were in separate silos inside Verizon that created a barrier to working together. But it’s hard to think this couldn’t have been worked out over the last two decades. My guess is there was an internal battle since no division wanted to get saddled with swallowing the bundling discount.

The carriers will be trying other ways to increase customer loyalty. AT&T just announced that it will guarantee to have a live expert on every customer call within five minutes. If a customer has to wait more than five minutes, a customer will get either a $5 billing credit or a $25 accessory coupon. This guarantee covers more than 50 million customers. I have to wonder how many people think five minutes is a fast response time.

AT&T is also offering discounts if a fiber customer has an outage of more than 20 minutes or a wireless customer has an outage of more than 60 minutes. AT&T is also promising the same-day or next-day technician availability for fiber issues.

There is a long way to go before T-Mobile has a workable cellular product. While they have a lot of money, it’s a massive effort to buy and install the needed cellular equipment at 80,000 cell sites. I’m still trying to get my mind around the SpaceX cellular business plan. The company wants to enter a market where prices are dropping, and competition is already fierce.

The big differentiator for SpaceX is using satellite backhaul instead of fiber backhaul. I have to wonder if that is really less expensive after factoring in having to replace the satellites every five years. The three big cell companies also operate an extensive network of retail locations. Is SpaceX going to spend the money to duplicate that, or will they stick with online customer service? Starlink already has a pretty poor rating from the public for customer service, and cellular customers come to expect good service. While SpaceX might eventually become a formidable cellular competitor, they have a huge amount of work to do to get there. It seems pretty silly to punish the stock prices of existing carriers for an event that may or may not materialize years from now.

How We Use Cellphones

Pew Research Center recently released its 2026 report on Americans’ Use of Mobile Devices. Pew has been conducting annual surveys that ask about cellphone ownership and use since 2004. The statistics in the report are based on a survey of 5,511 U.S. adults and have an overall margin of error of plus or minus 1.8 percentage points.

In a statistic that surprises nobody, 98% of adults have a cellphone and 91% of Americans use smartphones. But it hasn’t always been this high. The survey from ten years ago. at the beginning of 2016, showed that 92% of Americans had a cellphone, but only 70% had a smartphone.

The survey shows that cellphone ownership is related to age. 100% of those between 18 and 29 had a cellphone, compared to 96% for those over 65. The statistics are more drastic for people who have a cellphone that is not a smartphone, with only 1% of those between 18 and 29 in this category, while 14% of cellphone users over age 65 don’t have a smartphone.

The survey also asks about the relationship between cellphones and broadband usage. 16% of Americans don’t have home broadband and only get broadband from their cellphone. That percentage has held fairly steady since 2019. The survey shows that demographic factors seem to make a big difference in those who rely on cellphones for broadband:

  • The most obvious factor is household income. 12% of people living in homes with annual household incomes between $70,000 and $100,000 rely on cellphones for broadband, while 29% of those living in homes with annual incomes under $30,000 rely on smartphones. It’s not a stretch to say that folks living in homes that can’t afford a broadband connection have no choice but to rely on a cellphone.
  • Along the same lines, only 11% of residents in suburbs rely only on a cellphone, while 20% of residents in urban and rural areas do. The differences are likely due to household incomes, but the rural statistic probably also speaks to the poor cellular coverage in many rural areas.
  • The level of education also tells a similar story, with 9% of those with a college degree relying only on a cellphone, while 23% of those with a high school or less education do.
  • Race seems to make a significant difference, with 13% of whites relying only on a cellphone for broadband while 23% of Hispanics do.
  • Age correlation is interesting. 24% of those between 18 and 29 rely only on a cellphone, while other age groups are between 12% and 16%. There could be a lot of factors behind those statistics. Lower incomes for young households could be an issue. But overall mobility and the willingness to take advantage of sources of WiFi might also make a big difference.
  • As you might expect, there is not much difference by gender.

One of the most interesting parts of the report is showing all of the statistics over time. I wonder how many people remember that in 2004 only 65% of adults had a cellphone – and none of them were smartphones.

Beware the Smartwatches

I recently subscribed to Wired and was reading some back issues. I ran across a disturbing article from August: Hackers Stalked Me by Hijacking a Smartwatch for Kids by Andy Greenberg, a Wired reporter.

The article describes how a friendly hacker in Greece was able to track a WIRED reporter walking around Manhattan with a cheap pink child’s smartwatch. The hacker was able to track everywhere the reporter walked around town by seeing the smartwatch from the various WiFi signals that permeate the urban area. This means that somebody can be following a kid everywhere they go with a smartwatch, even if they aren’t wearing it and it’s in a backpack.

If that’s not scary enough, the hacker was able to hack into both the camera and the microphone on the smartwatch and could see and hear everything within range of the watch. The hacker was able to overhear conversations, like one with a coworker of the reporter describing their weekend. The smartwatch gave no indication that the camera or microphone were being used.

The smartwatch in question was a supercheap watch that cost only $30 and was sold by an obscure Chinese company called CJC and was manufactured by YiQingTeng Electronics, in Shenzhen, China. The team that hacked the smartwatch presented their findings at the Black Hat cybersecurity conference. They had identified more than 70 GPS-enabled watches and car accessories that could be hacked in the same way. All of these devices worked on several different platforms in China.

You might ask how this is possible. After all, doesn’t the FCC have to approve all smartwatches and similar devices sold in the U.S.? The answer is yes – the FCC must approve all devices that use Bluetooth, WiFi, cellular, and NFC (intentional radiators) to ensure that radio emissions from the device stay within legal limits and don’t interfere with other electronic equipment. Because smartwatches are worn next to the human body, the FCC also evaluates the devices for the specific absorption rate (SAR) and maximum permissible exposure to ensure safety.

Unfortunately, the FCC doesn’t check for cybersecurity flaws, and if they had to do so, they probably wouldn’t be able to approve any devices. This is particularly so now that AI is poking into the cybersecurity flaws of electronic devices of all kinds. Even if a smartwatch had good cybersecurity systems when it was made, there is no mechanism to update security patches for flaws detected after it was sold. This is unfortunately true for most wireless devices. But even when there are security patches available, a huge number of users don’t install updates, even if they know about them.

What is ironic about this is that people who bought Meta smartglasses are regularly being shunned in public places or even being forbidden to enter. But nobody is worried about smartwatches or the many other new types of wearables like rings, pendants, and similar devices. There is also a whole array of sports and health monitoring devices on the market that can be similarly hacked.

This all makes me wish for WiFi and Bluetooth jamming devices that public places could install to make patrons feel safe. But I’m sure the FCC would say that isn’t allowed.

Vetting ISPs

In the recent October meeting, the FCC adopted a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that would set tighter vetting rules for any ISP that applies for funding from the high-cost programs in the Universal Service Fund. This FCC action is the result of directions from Congress in May 2026 in the Rural Broadband Protection Act.

A lot of the impetus behind this FCC’s action is the huge number of defaults in the FCC’s Rural Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF). That program did basically zero vetting and let ISPs bid in a reverse auction to bring broadband to rural Census blocks across the country.

One of the provisions of the new FCC rules is to increase the penalty for ISP defaults from $3,000 per location today to at least $9,000 per location in the future. Anyone that still plans to default on RDOF locations should do so before this NPRM is adopted.

Undoubtedly, good vetting would have stopped some of the companies that won in the RDOF auction. The biggest RDOF winner that didn’t get funded was LTD Broadband, which had won $1.32 billion from the RDOF auction to serve 528,000 locations. It’s hard to call that a default since the FCC booted LTD Broadband from the RDOF process after it concluded that the small company didn’t have the financial or technical wherewithal to meet its obligations. The FCC also booted Starlink from RDOF when it concluded that the company couldn’t meet the speed requirements of 100/20 Mbps.

But there were also a lot of companies that truly defaulted on the locations won in the reverse auction. A number of companies walked away soon after the auction when they only won some of the locations they had bid on, and what was left in their winnings didn’t create a sensible network. In my opinion, these defaults can be pinned on the FCC and its dumb idea to award RDOF by Census blocks instead of by sensible study areas.

But there were dozens of other ISPs who have walked away from some or all of RDOF winnings. This ranges from small ISPs to giant ISPs like Charter and Lumen. Better vetting might have eliminated some of these defaults, such as WISPs who won RDOF with a promise to build fiber. But I also lay most of these defaults at the feet of the FCC. The RDOF reverse auction ended in November 2020, but companies had far too long to meet their buildout requirements. There are still RDOF winners who have not completed the construction, and some of them are not required to do so until the end of 2027. The whole idea of giving companies that long of a time frame to build a broadband network was ridiculous from the start.

Maybe the ISPs were naïve in having business plans that underestimated the cost of inflation in the broadband industry. But to give credit to ISPs, inflation had not been much of an issue in the decade before the reverse auction. The rate of broadband inflation soared soon after the end of the auction and has remained higher than the overall economy’s inflation rate. Nobody who won RDOF could have foreseen the gigantic changes in the broadband industry. Huge amounts of federal grants were released as a result of the pandemic. Big ISPs like AT&T decided to build fiber to tens of millions of passings. Fiber valuations climbed, and dozens of venture-capital-backed ISPs entered the market.

All of the market changes pushed up the cost to build networks. Labor rates for experienced fiber technicians rose much faster than inflation. Supply chain shortages during and after the pandemic ran up the cost of many routine components, like anything that included resin. In recent years, the explosion in chip prices has meant skyrocketing costs for all electronics. Breakthroughs in wireless technologies brought faster speeds, but at much higher component costs. Pole attachments and rights-of-way cost more and took a lot longer than expected, especially when trying to cross federal lands. ISPs who had a solid business plan in 2020 found that they are better off financially by paying the penalties instead of building networks that costs too much.

We’re still not finished with RDOF defaults. For example, I know electric cooperatives that are thinking about walking away from their small remaining RDOF obligations that are outside of the cooperative footprint. I lay this blame on the FCC as well, since making broadband awards by Census block is far different than the way that ISPs would choose to expand. Networks follow roads, and ISPs design networks that way. Service areas by Census Block invariably include small pockets that are not connected to the rest of the Census block. There are going to be other defaults by RDOF winners who have delayed defaults to avoid the penalties. We just heard last week that Cox is walking away from its remaining RDOF obligations.

It’s hard to not agree that ISPs should be vetted better before receiving federal broadband funding. But when the basis of vetting ISPs better is largely aimed at the huge problems caused by RDOF defaults, perhaps the better answer is to get the FCC out of the business of funding network construction. They aren’t staffed for it, and I doubt they have the operational experience to properly vet ISPs if there ever were another big subsidy program. The funniest thing about this NPRM is that there are no more big blocks of unserved locations, just scattered small pockets all over the country. It’s highly unlikely that there will ever be another program like RDOF again, so this legislation and the resulting FCC action are largely meaningless.

California BEAD Funding on Hold

It sounds like California and NTIA are at an impasse over releasing the $1.42 billion in BEAD funds to the state to support broadband infrastructure grants, with the controversy involving net neutrality.

Before diving deeper into the details of the dispute, let me provide the context behind the disagreement. California passed net neutrality legislation in September 2018. The California net neutrality rules are similar to what eventually was approved by the FCC. The U.S. Department of Justice and others immediately sued California over the legislation, which put implementation of the law on hold. The California law was finally upheld in January 2022 by a unanimous ruling of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

The FCC under Chairperson Jessica Rosenworcel adopted federal net neutrality rules in April 2024. You may recall that the docket had millions of comments filed by the public, the most ever for an FCC proceeding. The FCC ruling was also challenged in court. In January 2025, the U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the FCC lacked the legal authority to order net neutrality, partially based on the Supreme Court’s Loper Bright decision that said that federal agencies didn’t have the authority to make major rulings that had not been directed by Congress. The new FCC Chairman Brendan Carr did not appeal the court ruling since reversing the net neutrality ruling was high on his agenda for the FCC. The court relieved the FCC from having to vote on the issue.

The final step for flowing federal grant funds to states is for the state to sign an agreement before the money flows. There are thousands of grants every year that flow between federal agencies and states, and the grant agreements between states and the federal government are routine and noncontroversial. However, NTIA added a requirement to the BEAD grant agreement that says that a state must agree to not impose any net neutrality rules on any BEAD winner – not just for BEAD-funded areas, but statewide.

On November 2, California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) President John Reynolds told NTIA that the CPUC does not interpret the federal grant conditions in the BEAD agreement to require California to forfeit its legal rights or to stop enforcing an existing state law. He said that California will sign the BEAD grant agreement as long as the net neutrality provision doesn’t apply. NTIA responded almost immediately and said that California has to sign the agreement as written and that there are no exceptions to what has been offered in the agreement. This means BEAD funding is at an impasse and won’t flow to California ISPs until this issue is resolved.

For some more context, the original BEAD legislation did not require that BEAD recipients follow net neutrality. However, NTIA under the Biden administration added the net neutrality requirement after the FCC approved net neutrality rules. After the courts struck down the FCC’s net neutrality rules, NTIA under the Trump administration removed the requirement that BEAD recipients must follow net neutrality.

However, NTIA went one step further and said that states had to agree not to enforce state net neutrality laws in order to get the BEAD funding. All other states have agreed to the NTIA agreement. It was clear to everybody in the industry that NTIA added this provision specifically for California, since it was the only state that has serious state net neutrality rules. NTIA was teeing up this battle with California from the start.

What’s interesting about this fight is that ISPs, even the big ones, have not done anything blatantly in violation of net neutrality rules in many years. In a time of social media attention and heightened competition, ISPs don’t want to get painted as discriminating against customers or their internet traffic. This fight, instigated by NTIA, is clearly not about net neutrality, since that is not a big problem. This is a political fight, and another way for the administration to stick it to California.

There is a very good chance that the issue will not be resolved. It’s hard to see NTIA or California give in on the issue. It’s always possible this will go to court, but that would likely take years. What I find most ironic about this dispute is that the courts ruled that the FCC couldn’t implement net neutrality rules. It seems even less likely that courts would side with NTIA for arbitrarily making a backdoor regulatory ruling that is far outside of its congressional mandate.

Meanwhile, the practical consequence is that California BEAD projects will not get funded by the NTIA. My bet, if that happens, is that California will fund the grants, and in doing so will impose other state rules like the requirement to have low prices. The state might even put in more money than what came out of the Benefit of Bargain rules and might fund more fiber.

The Election and Broadband Policy

I rarely write about politics, but it’s hard not to think that the blue wave election on November 3 will result in some changes in broadband policy and programs.

Of course, there is a chance that there will be little or no change in the short run. The new Congress might get so wrapped up in other issues that broadband won’t make it to the top of their pile. It’s also possible that the Trump administration and agencies will dig their heels in and fight everything proposed by the new Democratic majority and might pretend the election never occurred. I certainly don’t have any crystal ball when it comes to predicting Congress and the White House.

But there are some areas where a new Congress could change the trajectory of various broadband issues. This list is purely my speculation, but these all seem more possible than just a few weeks ago.

USF Reform. There was already a bipartisan, bicameral congressional working group examining ideas for modernizing and stabilizing the Universal Service Fund. We don’t know precisely what this group has been discussing. We can guess that they have been looking at possibly changing some of the USF programs. But their main stated purpose has been to look at the stability of the USF, and that means considering a new funding mechanism to replace the badly outdated fees based on interstate telephone traffic.

It’s also possible that the group has been discussing changes to specific programs. It seems likely to me that a new Congress might take a harder look at beefing up the Lifeline program. There are a lot of people in the industry hoping for an increase in the monthly $9.25 subsidy to make it more useful and more in line with the success we saw in the short-lived ACP funding.

Fix the USAC Issue. Congress could easily solve the outcome of the recent court case where the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the FCC never had the authority to create USAC. A very short piece of legislation could solve the issue by giving the FCC the needed specific authority.

BEAD Non-Deployment Funds. There is huge support from every state for NTIA to disperse the $22 billion of BEAD non-deployment funds as was intended by the BEAD legislation. In fact, many red states are among the loudest yelling for these funds. The new majority, and perhaps a bipartisan majority, could put a lot of pressure on NTIA to make this happen. This is the kind of requirement that could be added to a budget reconciliation bill or another piece of legislation. States also want discretion on how to use the funds and don’t want NTIA dictating only a narrow list of the ways the money can be used. States are in favor of the uses described in the original legislation.

Digital Equity Grants. While funding for these grants is slowly moving forward again as part of a court settlement between NTIA and NDIA, Congress could speed this up and require it to happen quickly. There are still a lot of folks I know who are leery that NTIA will actually pull the trigger on these grants, even though they have promised some early steps (that are already late). Congress could make this happen.

Various Other Issues. A new Congress could resolve other issues like the fight that is brewing between California and NTIA over freeing BEAD grant funding to the state. NTIA wants California to preempt its own laws on net neutrality as a condition for releasing the BEAD funding. It could get very interesting if Congress gets involved in the increasingly unpopular copper decommissioning, including the FCC’s attempt to override California regulations of the issue. It doesn’t seem far-fetched for Congress to tell the FCC to back off from meddling in the content of TV programming.

The Copper Disconnection Notice

AT&T, Verizon, and other telcos have stepped up their efforts to discontinue copper. Suddenly, hundreds of thousands of rural homeowners and businesses are getting the notice that their copper will be cut dead, usually within 90 days.

Here is rural Western North Carolina, and around the country, cutting copper is suddenly a big local issue. The telcos have been telling regulators for a decade that this day was coming, but that knowledge never filtered down to the public. The process of cutting copper got a big boost over the last year when the FCC simplified the disconnection paperwork for telcos and made it easier for telcos to accelerate the process.

AT&T told stockholders a year ago that it intended to decommission all copper by the end of 2029. Last month, the company told stockholders it now wants to accelerate and beat that date. Verizon has quietly been killing copper for the last five years, and the company most recently requested permission to eliminate copper in nine states: Arizona, Delaware, New Jersey, New Mexico, Ohio, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Utah, and Virginia – in areas that were formally part of Frontier. The company was likely surprised when the FCC put that request on hold pending more questions. The FCC is siding with the big telcos and recently decided to try to overturn the delays on decommissioning copper put in place by the California Public Utilities Commission.

Unfortunately, the new FCC rules place the entire burden of disputing the loss of copper on the customer. A customer has the right to seek a delay in copper decommissioning if they are going to lose access to 911 and if they have no alternative way to buy voice. Following is a description of some of the major hoops a customer would have to jump through to delay the process of losing copper, and as you will see, the deck is fully stacked against the public.

By FCC rule, a customer has only fifteen days to officially protest or comment after the FCC approves a given notice of discontinuance. I know what I’m going to say next sounds preposterous, but for a customer to realistically know that copper is going to be cut, they would need to keep track of what’s being ordered at the FCC to even know that a docket has been issued for their local area, and then quickly file comments if the customer doesn’t want to lose copper. There are practically no customers in the country ready or able to do this.

The process of tracking where copper will be discontinued is a challenge even for those who understand the FCC process. The FCC publishes a daily list of formal actions in the Daily Digest. Copper decommissioning orders are mixed in with other orders and are labeled something like, “Discontinue Domestic Legacy Voice Service as Part of a Technology Transition”. It’s routinely challenging to understand the specific geography the FCC orders are covering. But if a customer could figure this out, the next step would be to find the applicable proceeding related to the discontinuance docket at this FCC site. If a customer can figure out the specific docket that applies to them, a customer can file online comments, where they can describe the problems that will be caused if they lose their copper. As you might imagine, very few consumers have made it through this process.

One of the key elements to delay losing copper is that the customer must have no alternative service. That could mean having a broadband alternative that would allow for VoIP. It might mean having access to cellular service. Carriers and the FCC are going to rely on the FCC broadband and cellular coverage maps. I’ve been writing blogs for years describing how inaccurate these maps are, particularly in rural areas. The cellular coverage maps are particularly egregious and often greatly exaggerate actual coverage. But to win the argument for a delay, a customer has to somehow show there is no actual alternative, and we all know how hard it is to prove a negative.

Some customers may have additional time to act beyond the statutory time frame. Verizon, for the recently acquired Frontier properties, has told customers that they won’t cut them off if there is no alternative to reach 911. However, there is no specific mechanism for customers to make this claim to Verizon. A customer could try to directly convince them of this, while a better place would be to go through the FCC docket system.

Unfortunately, I wish I had something more positive to tell folks about losing copper. Probably the best outcome a customer can hope for is to delay losing copper for a while. But within a few years, big telco copper is going to be gone, and the FCC will close all of the copper dockets.

Satellite News November 2026

Starlink Testing Dynamic Pricing

PC Magazine recently announced it has evidence that Starlink is experimenting with dynamic pricing. Starlink told customers in some markets that their prices might be increased or decreased based on the number of customers in a region. The reporter obtained a notice from Starlink warning that prices could change quarterly based on regional demand. The article cites one Missouri customer who said on Reddit that the price of the $50 plan had been changed to $60.50. There was a Missouri Starlink customer on Facebook who said that the $130 plan had been increased to $156 per month. In both cases, this is a rate increase of roughly 20%.

This is the kind of pricing that has been used for years by airlines to extract the highest possible revenue out of each flight. This may just be my opinion, but I have to think that customers who are charged more because their ISP is doing too well are going to seek out any other ISP. It doesn’t seem like a formula for creating long-term customer trust.

Amazon LEO Broadband by End of the Year

Amazon says it still plans to introduce its initial broadband service before the end of the year. This should be a limited launch that will only cover a portion of the country. The company says that it recently completed the manufacturing of its 1,000th broadband satellite. Amazon currently has around 400 satellites in orbit and is waiting for launch windows to launch more satellites. The company is also hopeful that it will get back on track with launches of its Blue Origin and its New Glenn rockets. The company already has reserved space on several launches that will still happen this year.

FCC Approved Amazon Leo’s Acquisition of Globalstar

The FCC approved Amazon’s $11.5 billion acquisition of Globalstar. This will give Amazon an immediate entry into the direct-to-device business of providing cellular service to cellphones. Globalstar will become a fully owned subsidiary of Amazon and will retain its corporate name. Globalstar currently has 54 active satellites in orbit and an aggressive plan for launches in 2027.

SpaceX to Attempt to Capture the Starship Upper Stage

SpaceX is going to attempt the next big improvement in space launch economics by trying to capture both the upper and lower stages from each Starship launch. This will allow the company to develop a rapidly reusable platform to be able to support more satellite launches. Today, the company recovers the booster as it falls back to Earth. The plan to capture the upper stage will involve a complicated maneuver where the upper ship will do a belly flop and enter a controlled descent, where the upper ship will then be captured by chopstick-like arms extended from a tower.

FAA To Streamline Launch Rules

The Federal Aviation Administration is proposing to streamline regulations for commercial space launches and re-entries. The agency is creating an online portal that will allow automated launch applications, giving more flexibility to change when launch windows change due to weather or technical issues. The White House has said that it wants the country to have the ability to have 1,000 launches and re-entries per year by 2030. To put that into context, there were 178 launches in 2025. The launch rules are a big deal because commercial airlines have to avoid the flight paths due to the potential for debris when launches go poorly, as we’ve seen a few times in recent years. Airlines must be cringing at the idea of somehow scheduling around 1,000 events per year.

Minimum Digital Living Standard

The New Mexico Office of Broadband Access & Expansion (OBAE) issued a press release that announced the creation of what they are calling the Minimum Digital Living Standard (MDLS). OBAE has opened a proceeding that will accept public comments until December 9, asking for comments on how it should establish an MDLS.

As a reminder, New Mexico is the only state that has funded a broadband subsidy program that largely mimics the expired federal Affordable Connectivity Plan (ACP). OBAE is asking how it should set the minimum broadband benchmark for every home in the state.

The question of setting a minimum digital living standard highlights some of the serious digital gaps in the state. New Mexico is a diverse state with diverse populations, challenging topography, and many languages. There are a significant number of Tribal areas in the state. According to OBAE, 23% of New Mexicans lack a desktop or laptop computer. 38.4% of New Mexicans live in rural areas. 26.5% face language barriers. 42% of households struggle to afford basic daily necessities, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.

OBAE recognizes in its questions that many daily essentials have moved online and that the average family now also needs to worry about issues like cybersecurity, privacy, and consumer protection.

OBAE suggests that the definition of a minimum digital living standard should consider all of the following factors:

Access and Equipment:

  • Affordable, reliable internet
  • Adequate devices

Functional Knowledge and Skills

  • Setting up and configuring devices
  • Doing tasks online
  • Managing devices and connections

Critical Knowledge and Skills

  • Evaluating online content and information
  • Evaluating what to share online
  • Managing safety, security and privacy
  • Maintaining digital balance

OBAE wants to incorporate the MDLS into its current 2026-2028 three-year plan. The state’s goal is to have “a fully connected New Mexico where every community has universal access to affordable, high-quality, future-ready broadband, while honoring the state’s diversity and rich heritage, strengthening opportunity, propelling future technologies, and elevating quality of life for every resident.”

This is an interesting goal, because it’s a very different approach than the FCC arbitrarily declaring that the only definition of good broadband is a connection that delivers a speed of 100/20 Mbps. While the OBAE definition will likely include a speed target, it is also going to include goals for affordability and for digital inclusion issues like the availability of devices and the knowledge of how to use them.