Troubles at Brightspeed

This story falls into the category of déjà vu all over again. I can’t recall a company that has purchased a large swath of copper plant from the big telcos that didn’t eventually get into financial trouble. This happened to Frontier. It happened years ago to FairPoint in New England, and to Iowa Telecom.

Brightspeed purchased a lot of rural, poorly maintained, and neglected copper assets from Lumen. I call what came next déjà vu, since Brightspeed immediately began investing in replacing copper with fiber. That’s exactly what was needed for the millions of customers in the Brightspeed footprint.

However, every one of the companies that purchased big copper networks ran into the same two problems. First, they didn’t get much in the way of useful backoffice infrastructure and had to immediately begin putting together the needed organization and systems – at the same time that they were taking over a disgruntled customer base. The companies all got some copper technicians but mostly didn’t get the staff they needed to efficiently operate the business.

The bigger problem for every one of these companies was that they quickly became buried in debt as they spent money on upgrades. Brightspeed finds itself staring at $11.6 billion in debt. The company is profitable, and by any standard other than the debt load, it is doing well. But Brightspeed is said to be $3 billion short of the cash it needs to make it through debt payments due in 2027.

Brightspeed is taking the kinds of steps that are needed to make it through the financial distress. They’ve hired Shawn O’Donnell this month as the new CEO. He has extensive experience in telecom turnarounds. The company is already preparing for a potential bankruptcy. Brightspeed is backed by Apollo Global Management, which is said to be seeking additional capital through asset-backed financing based on the many new fiber networks.

Brightspeed has also been highly successful in winning grant funding. For example, the company won over $528 million in BEAD grants to bring fiber to 183,000 rural locations. But fundiing those new locations adds to the financial stress.

Customers have been complaining about problems with Brightspeed service. Customers have complained about the common occurrence of multi-day outages. There are complaints of long wait times until technicians show up to fix problems. Customers are complaining about long hold times when calling customer service.

These kinds of problems are not unusual for somebody buying copper networks. While Brightspeed has converted a lot of customers to fiber, it is still fighting to prop up a number of obsolete copper networks. Many of its markets are isolated, and a single cut to a middle-mile route can knock out a whole region. This is not to make excuses for Brightspeed, but its problems were completely predictable for anybody who understood the complete garbage networks they inherited. Technicians have told me that in many rural networks, Lumen had stopped doing maintenance for many years before dumping the properties.

I am certain that at some point Brightspeed will make it through this tough period, as the other companies did. The fiber networks it has been building will drive a successful business plan for years to come. But if you look at the other companies like Frontier and FairPoint, the road to long-term success might mean being absorbed by a larger ISP. At best, it probably means the original equity and debt holders will have to swallow cuts and that more ownership will go to the venture capital backers.

Leave a Reply