New Mexico recently released an RFI asking stakeholders how the state should decide on structuring future broadband grants. New Mexico remains as one of the states with the most broadband gaps, and it’s clear the state plans to continue to have grant programs to address the various gaps. The State has already launched a program to address broadband affordability that largely mimics what was offered by the federal ACP plan. But the state recognizes there are still a lot of other gaps.
This is something I’ve been thinking a lot about lately, because it’s also a big topic in Western North Carolina. This region also has a lot of broadband gaps, many of which were made worse by Hurricane Helene. There has been a lot of talk in the region about how we build back smarter.
The discussion in Western North Carolina and New Mexico acknowledges that there are still numerous infrastructure gaps that haven’t been filled by grant funding. Both regions, and much of the rest of the country, still have:
- Pockets of folks who haven’t been reached by terrestrial broadband.
- A lot of places where federal grants went for satellite service.
- Major gaps in rural cellphone coverage.
- Gaps in rural public safety networks.
- A lot of people who live out of easy range of a health facility.
- Anchor institutions that haven’t gotten fiber broadband.
- Low-income housing complexes with inadequate broadband.
- Hurricane Helene showed Western North Carolina is that there is also a huge gap in redundancy and resiliency in existing networks. Too many counties in the region had lengthy communications blackouts. We are now working on creating resiliency hubs where folks can go for emergency food, power, and WiFi after a disaster.
- Middle-mile fiber to support all of the above.
I think the solution is to build smarter. It’s going to be tempting for New Mexico to launch grant programs that address only one specific issue, like lack of rural cell towers. While such grants will be welcome, they will spend infrastructure money without considering the many other broadband gaps.
There is a better way. What if every broadband infrastructure proposal was graded not on how it solved a specific issue, but also by how many other needs it could satisfy? This would be a new way to think about infrastructure grants.
There is a better way to tackle new grants today. We have the resources to map all of the gaps described above. Before New Mexico issues any infrastructure grants, it should first fund a broadband gap map that identifies every location that still needs an infrastructure solution. The map would show each of the gaps described above.
There is a logistical challenge in how to populate the gaps on the initial maps. There are already state agencies that track some of the gaps. Other gaps can be identified by experts. For example, it’s not hard with AI to identify the places where a new cell tower would reach the most people who don’t have cell coverage today.
Creating such a map one time would be great, but the best use of the knowledge embedded in a broadband gap map would be to update it, at least annually. That would involve removing sites that have gotten a broadband solution in the last year, and adding new sites as people figure them out.
These maps would be made public. They would be of great value to ISPs since they would identify revenue opportunities they might not have known about. And of course, they would be invaluable when issuing middle-mile or last-mile infrastructure grants, since the maps would show areas with the greatest needs in a number of areas.
A broadband gap map could also unleash non-profit and other efforts. For example, health organizations might decide to bring solutions to the areas with poor health coverage. State public safety folks could identify the coverage gaps while also seeing the other benefits from issuing public safety grants. Identifying the areas with no redundancy can alert local officials to start clamoring for a solution.
Are we just ignoring the fact that Starlink exists almost everywhere and is more than fast enough for any internet usage now or in the future? I’m looking at repair bills in the thousands of dollars for damage done to my vehicles due to the absolute atrocious state of the roads in my area. Every single dollar our local government puts into making sure internet is almost free makes me highly irritated.
I would hazard a guess the average person in America spends more on their vehicle in a year for repairs than they do on internet service.
This is stupid